Table of Contents

Hard Disk Drives

see also:

Replacement policy suggestion

Every spinning drives with pending/moved sectors or uncorrectable errors MUST be replaced.

Most drives can pull about 40k-50k power on hours. To keep things fresh, you SHOULD phase them out at 35k hours (=24h/d*365d/y*4y) or 4 years. Then they can be used as archive HDDs or cold spares, but SHOULD NOT be trusted with data you only have once.

If you feel fancy, you CAN replace disks at 20,000 hours.

General suggestions

Model recommendations

NAS

Name Capacity €/TB Net price Comments
Seagate Archive 5TB 30,14€ 150€ optimised for cold storage
Seagate Archive 6TB 31,11€ 190€
Seagate Skyhawk 10TB 28,90€ 289€ optimised for surveillance (much write)
WD RED 3TB 32,49€ 100€
WD RED 4TB 34,44€ 140€
Toshiba N300 8TB loud (7200rpm without He)

Desktop

Name Capacity €/TB Net price
Seagate BarraCuda Compute 2TB 2TB 26,40€ 53€

ext. case

Name USB SATA Net price
RaidSonic Icy Box IB-366StU3+B B 3.0 6 Gb/s 32€

hot plugging

Both your mainboard and your HDD have to support hot swapping.

Even if your mainboard generally supports hot swap, your mainboard may not support it on all ports. Similarly, if your disks themselves don't support hot swap, you can't hot swap them even in a mainboard which supports it.

Swapping disks while the PC is booted should only be done if you're absolutely certain both the mainboard and the disk support hot swapping properly, else you may damage the disk. Especially consumer-grade disks are susceptible to failures in this way.

Being on standby may simply mean they have parked their r/w arms and are still spinning. It does not mean you can hot swap the disks.

FAQ

Can I shout at my disks?

No, you should not shout in the data centre. If you do, your disk arrays might throw read errors.